
In the Early Years (EY) sector we have created quite the marketplace for organisations to approach consultants, trainers, speakers and the like, and ask to work with us in exchange for exposure and reach. It can be competitive and mentally unhealthy. This blog post has come about due to ongoing situations that myself and colleagues encounter that are related to the expectation that we provide our knowledge and skills for free with no regard to payment for the service we provide. This blog also seeks to address how this is problematic when asking Black people and people of colour to work for free especially when the topic of that contribution is on anti-racism or topics pertaining to diversity and inclusion.
I am not going to lie; I have been part of the problem. I remember the first time I got a call inviting me to speak at the West Midlands Ofsted Big Conversation. I felt over the moon! I had been self-employed for about 12 months or so working as an early years consultant. I always felt chuffed, like I was getting somewhere when I got asked by the NDNA, EY Alliance, Childcare Expo, Nursery World, Early Years Educator, to speak at an event or contribute to a magazine. It was like they were doing me a favour and not the other way round.
How did we get here? Our entire sector is undervalued so we must consider that often funding is low, there isn’t much money spare for people to attend training, never mind pay for training. Social media has a part to play in the way we now access professional development. We have fed into this dynamic of expecting training for free. So, this issue is complex and there is no single cause or solution.
When Covid hit and paid work disappeared, it started to sit differently when approached as the free work ramped up as everything moved online and when asked to continually share knowledge and create content I and others began to question this. As a community of fellow consultants, trainers and speakers we must consider that our socio-economic background will determine how much content some of us are able to share for free. Are we setting up our community of specialists to fail by offering services for free, when others have no choice but to charge to generate an income?
“The work of anti-racism is becoming a better human to other humans. You have the capacity to be a better human – would you accept that invitation?”
(Austin Channing Brown, 2020)
We have to acknowledge how the murder of George Floyd in 2020 ignited fury and conversation across the world, which extends and includes the EY sector. It has been hard to ignore the work of Liz Pemberton the Black Nursery Manager and her ground-breaking work on anti-racist EY practice. Or the work of Laura Henry Allain, Shaddai Tembo, Jamel Carly Campbell, Shada Lambert and Joss Cambridge Simmonds.
Many of us have been engaged in understanding anti-racism work and are on a learning journey along with an unlearning journey. This has led to a growing awareness of social justice and the lack of representation of marginalised communities within our EY sector. This also leads to the realisation that the EY sector tends to be represented by white people, both in senior positions within the prominent organisations that make up our sector and also within settings and at training events and panels.
However, some seem determined not to engage, speak out and show an unwillingness to engage in conversation on this subject and we continue to see a lack of representation in line-ups, events and publications. The lack of representation and inclusion in our EY sector is depriving us of valuable insights, perspectives, and experiences. In the UK white people make up the majority and Black people and people of colour are the minority. Yet globally colleagues who are racialised as other, are the global majority. Black people and people of colour make up our communities both within our workforce and as our children and families.
“Perfectionism is NOT a prerequisite to participation. You can actively work on diversity in your daily life AND use your voice against injustice at the same time” (Danielle Coke)
I know many like-minded EY colleagues will now ask about representation when invited into these spaces to contribute. This is to ensure that the event is engaged in an intersectional approach to EY pedagogy. For example, is there a representation of race, a non-dominant cultural perspective, religion, class, language, regional dialect, gender, sexuality, neurodivergence, disabilities, mental and physical health experinces?
This enables our workforce to see themselves and their lived experience represented which leads to a more authentic event that enables us to understand our colleagues, children and families on a deeper level. This results in a higher quality event and supports the personal and professional development of us all – not just offering space to shine the light on the dominant culture, gender or identity of a sector that is beautifully unique and diverse. This also leads us on a path to consider other factors, such as where we hold the event and who can attend based on the venue/location, accessibility, creating safe spaces within events, such as low arousal spaces, mental health first aiders to name a few.
What we also then must consider is, if we ask and invite colleagues to take part it is fundamentally wrong to ask colleagues to share their knowledge and lived experiences for free. In addition, asking a Black colleague to teach us about anti-racist practice if they are not an anti-racist practitioner is problematic and damaging. Likewise asking someone to share their approach to wellbeing based on their life’s work and known mental health issues is derogatory as is asking someone with ADHD + Autism to speak on SEND.
Let me be clear this is not about calling people out. This is about people being made accountable. We are all accountable. We have to get comfortable having uncomfortable conversations and hold ourselves and each other to account. This is all of us taking care of each other. This is about a community of care, inclusion and belonging. This is not about being right, it is about getting it right – for the sake of our colleagues, children and families.
As a cis-gender woman racialised as white, I realise I hold a lot of privilege. I have been consciously aware of the legacy I want to create. For me, that means saying no to events that are not inclusive and do not represent the sector I am so proud to work in. It also means using that privilege when I am invited into spaces and asking questions, however uncomfortable and confronting I and others find it. If I do not do this and we do not do this together it means new trainers, consultants, speakers and educators coming into the sector will continue to be asked to work for free, and that is damaging for them and our entire sector.
Let’s talk about inclusion riders
An inclusion rider or equity rider is a document that outlines a certain level of diversity and something that myself and Kerry Murphy have been discussing for some time. The rider might stipulate that a proportion of speakers or contributors be women, Black people and people of colour, LGBTQIA+, neurodivergent, people with disabilities or physical and mental health issues. Likewise, you can include information on fees, or how you work with charities and organisations. This is how we can hold ourselves and others to account, event organisers will not leave representation and inclusion to chance and invited contributors will know the event is equitable.
This is a call to action; the action being developing an EY inclusion rider to strengthen conversations about how we achieve equality in the EY. Register your interest here if you would like to play a part in working together and collaborating on the EY Inclusion rider.
An ethics of care
“Relationships are about building connections and sharing dedication for collective care and compassion. There should be an ethics of care, to ensure the protection of all, when sharing lived experiences through a personal and professional lens”.
Kerry Murphy
What we can do next:
- If you are organising an event, you have a duty to ensure representation that is intentional and not haphazard
- Asking clearly about representation when asked to be part of a panel or an event
- Asking clearly if this is a paid-for opportunity
- Creating your own inclusion rider, which states your professional and personal values and beliefs
- Speaking up in the spaces you get invited to ask questions, signposting to documents that will help the event organisers to plan an inclusive event
- When starting out or seeking collaboration with colleagues who share an intersectional approach to EY pedagogy and practice, it is important to consider identity that is different to our own. Ensure that meaningful actions lead to establishing a network of educators, speakers, trainers authors and consultants that does not limit us to rely on one individual to speak on behalf of or for their community or the topic at hand.
Resources and further reading
Speaker Rider for Meaningfully Inclusive Events
https://opennews.org/projects/speaker-rider/
Organising an event: a toolkit BAMEed
https://www.bameednetwork.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/Organising-an-event_-a-toolkit.pdf
How to make your events more diverse and inclusive
https://www.zoho.com/backstage/thegreenroom/how-to-make-your-events-more-diverse-and-inclusive.html
The Early Years Black List
https://www.theearlyyearsblacklist.com/
Why we capitalize ‘Black’ (and not ‘white’)
https://www.cjr.org/analysis/capital-b-black-styleguide.php
Associated Press changes influential style guide to capitalize ‘Black’
https://amp.theguardian.com/media/2020/jun/20/associated-press-style-guide-capitalize-black
Thank you to Anne Gladstone, Kerry Murphy and Liz Pemberton for their contribution and feedback that has enabled me to write this blog post.
